Pricing Strategy & Seasonality
Pricing, Seasonality & When to Capture ROI
Pricing Strategy
Rates spread widely, and space and position set them. Half of Saint Andrews listings charged C$265 a night or less in AirROI's latest twelve months; a quarter charged C$360 or more, a tenth C$555 or more, and the cheapest quarter C$195 or less. Three-bedroom homes averaged about C$357 a night at 54% occupancy and C$44,500 a year, two-bedroom homes C$292 at 53% and C$35,900, and one-bedroom places C$285 at 48% and C$33,900, so the third bedroom is where the rate steps up. In the months a listing was open for guests, the middle listing took in about C$3,660 and the top quarter C$5,450 or more. Grand Manan prices lower and books longer: a median of about C$200 a night, C$245 or more for the top quarter, stays averaging 5.5 nights and about C$2,850 for the median listing in an open month.
The C$3,070 in the box sits below those monthly figures because of how it's built: it takes the average listing's year, about C$36,790, and divides it across all twelve months, open or not. Only 45.6% of Saint Andrews listings were open for 271 days or more, and 41% were booked or blocked for just 91 to 180 days. Summer carries the year: July 2026 brought the average listing about C$8,750 and August about C$8,640, at roughly C$370 a night, while February brought about C$1,920. Two small changes move the total, by AirROI's arithmetic: selling ten more nights a year at the median rate adds about C$2,650, and charging 10% more on the nights you already sell adds about C$3,370. Subtract the Airbnb fee, cleaning and laundry, utilities, supplies, repairs, insurance and permit costs, about C$12,540 in AirROI's model, and the average listing is left with roughly C$24,250 a year, or C$2,020 a month, for its mortgage and property tax; the top quarter keeps about C$36,320.
Fees and settings shape what the guest sees at checkout. Most listings, 82.4% of them, add a cleaning fee, with a median of C$122 and an average of C$140, about C$27 a night at the median over the average 4.5-night stay, and cleaning fees make up 8.4% of gross revenue. Half the market uses a two-night minimum, a quarter accept one night, 16% ask for three and only 7% for four nights or more, and 61% use a firm or strict cancellation policy. August stays averaged five nights, so a summer minimum of four or five nights with a set changeover day suits the larger houses, while two nights fits the rest of the year. Guests here mark value lower than anything else, 4.86 against 4.95 overall, so the checkout total deserves as much care as the photos.
Quote the whole price. In Saint Andrews, Bayside and Chamcook, every stay of up to 31 days carries the 3.5% Tourism Accommodation Levy, which the town wants shown as its own line and which is not subject to HST, on top of New Brunswick's 15% HST where it applies. Airbnb takes care of GST/HST for hosts who aren't registered, but its list of Canadian local taxes has no New Brunswick entry, so the levy is the operator's to collect and remit on every booking, platform or direct; ask the town how it wants the levy shown on platform stays. A direct-booking site that adds rate, cleaning fee, HST and levy before the guest pays shows the real figure up front. Campobello, Deer Island, Grand Manan and St. Stephen lie outside the town, so its levy doesn't apply there; ask each local government whether it charges one of its own.
Seasonality & ROI Windows
The year here climbs steeply into summer. In AirROI's typical year for Saint Andrews, a listing earns about C$8,500 in August and C$1,910 in February, about 4.4 times as much, and the three strongest months bring in 45% of annual revenue. AirROI's high season runs June through September at about 62% occupancy, October is the shoulder at about 43%, and November through May averages about 33%. Summer guests plan early. Stays in July 2026 were booked about 132 days out on average and August's about 119; January's were booked about a month ahead and March's about 26 days. Grand Manan follows the same curve with an even stronger August, 80.5% occupancy in 2026, booked about 107 days ahead.
September and October hold up. September 2025 ran 57.5% occupancy at about C$315 a night and October 42.4% at C$304, and both beat every month from November to April. The fall has its own draws: whale tours run until the end of October, Ministers Island stayed open until October 18 in 2026, and the town's 2026 calendar had the 12th Charlotte County Pumpkin Festival at Kingsbrae Garden on October 10 and the Indulge Food & Wine Festival from October 16 to 18. Sell October in August: a line in the checkout message and a fall rate on your own site reach summer guests while they're still enjoying the house.
Winter is quiet but not empty. From November 2025 through April 2026, occupancy ran between about 28% and 37% at nightly rates of about C$278 to C$291, and guests booked roughly a month to two months ahead. March and April brought the longest stays of the year, 5.5 and 5.7 nights on average, so a weekly or monthly winter rate is worth testing. A winter listing should sell what keeps running: the ferries to Deer Island and Grand Manan cross all year, the town's arena calendar includes free public skating, and the Algonquin's USVA Thermal Experience adds outdoor hydrotherapy pools and saunas, so check its winter hours before you promise it. Kingsbrae Garden, closed for the winter, reopens on May 20, 2027, and the slow months are for reshooting photos, fixing what the summer wore out and writing next year's note to past guests.