Pricing Strategy & Seasonality
Pricing, Seasonality & When to Capture ROI
Pricing Strategy
AirROI's Archipelago figures describe a steep year with a high ceiling; like every AirROI number on this page, they were published in US dollars and are converted at about 1.39. From October 2025 through September 2026 the average listing charged about C$490 a night and was booked on 33% of its open nights, while the median listing charged about C$400 and was booked on 32%. A quarter of listings charged C$615 or more and a tenth C$815 or more, and the busiest tenth were booked on at least 64% of their nights. Revenue averaged about C$28,500 a listing, or C$2,380 a month, which is lower than nightly rate times occupancy because so many cottages rent only part of the year; AirROI's top-quarter listing grossed about C$50,500.
Summer carries the year. In August 2026 the average listing earned about C$11,700 at 63% occupancy and C$533 a night, and July about C$9,750 at 44% and C$539. Those monthly figures average only the cottages open in that month, while the annual average also counts cottages that opened for a few weeks, so twelve months of those figures add up to far more than the C$28,500 annual figure. In AirROI's two-year calendar August averages about C$10,500 a listing, about 4.3 times March's C$2,430, and the three strongest months, August, July and December, make up 42% of the twelve monthly averages added together. Rates hold steadier than occupancy, from about C$450 to C$465 a night between September and April to about C$535 in July and August, so the work outside summer is filling nights rather than cutting the price. A deep discount in May or September gives away rate that guests in those months have been paying.
The four municipalities price differently. McKellar's listings averaged about C$597 a night, 38% occupancy and C$60,400 a year, up 15.5% on the year, with August near C$16,500 a listing and February near C$2,820; 63% of them carry Airbnb's Guest Favorite badge. The Town of Parry Sound's 71 listings averaged C$304 a night at 40% occupancy and about C$26,700 a year; July is its best month, at about C$8,420 with 57% occupancy, and April its weakest. Carling averaged C$419 a night but only 27% occupancy and about C$20,550 a year, with a January in which listings filled under 5% of their nights. Across all four, rate is rarely the problem; the empty months are.
Stay rules follow the boat. In The Archipelago 40% of listings set a minimum stay of four to six nights and 11% a week or more, only 6% accept a single night, 43% use a firm cancellation policy and 17% allow Instant Book, which describes a market of planned, longer stays. Seventy-seven percent charge a cleaning fee, with a median of C$200, about 8.5% of gross revenue. AirROI's running-cost estimate for the average listing, covering Airbnb's fee, cleaning and laundry, utilities and internet, supplies, repairs, insurance and permits, comes to about C$9,100 a year, leaving about C$19,400 for housing costs before any profit. On an island a changeover means a boat trip for the cleaner and the linens as well as the guests, so price the turn into the stay: full weeks in July and August, a four-night minimum on either side of them, and a cleaning fee that reflects the crossing.
Seasonality & ROI Windows
The island season runs with the docks. The Archipelago's Holiday Cove Marina near Parry Sound set its 2026 season at April 27 to October 23, and every one of its 98 slips was taken. At Pointe au Baril, overnight dockage at the township wharf runs from Victoria Day weekend to the week after Labour Day, and the public washrooms there stay open until Thanksgiving Monday. AirROI's calendar follows the same arc: guests book about 108 days ahead for July stays and 90 days ahead for August, July stays average about seven nights, and October 2025 had the year's lowest occupancy, 19%. Sell summer early and by the week, to families who plan in the spring, and use the fall for the weekends before the docks come out; Carling, for one, has the Snug Harbour dock out for the season by November 16.
Winter belongs to the homes guests can drive to. AirROI's data shows a second, smaller season: December 2025 averaged about C$6,200 a listing with stays of about nine nights, and February 2026 filled 43% of its nights, the month of Ontario's Family Day long weekend. Those bookings come late, about 24 days ahead for December and 15 for February, and they can only go to winterized homes on a road, not island cottages that close with the marinas. Killbear Provincial Park runs a winter operation, from January 2 to March 16 in 2026, and Carling's Christmas Market, with more than 70 vendors, is set for November 1, 2026, which gives a winter listing near Carling something to offer beyond the fireplace. For an owner the plan is two products: an island or waterfront week in summer, sold early, and a short-stay winter or shoulder offer for the houses that can host it.